Also Read :What is a Promised Land and Why you should read this? Feb. 23, 2021 Dean Gribble, Jr. 4 MH-60 Jayhawk helicopter crews The devastating event took place in 2017, but will never be forgotten by Discovery fans who regularly tune in to the fishing-based show. 16 lost, 8 rescued. Five commercial fishermen are believed to have died on New Years Eve when their crab ship sank in the Gulf of Alaska, the U.S. Coast Guard said at the end of a search and rescue operation in high winds and rough seas. Feb 20, 1986. Some engineers have estimated its around 300 pounds. Who is the richest captain on Deadliest Catch? June 15, 2021. It is a month to month accounting of the most significant Alaska shipwrecks with transcribed stories taken directly from survivors. TheJayhawk helicopter crew KTOO collaborates with partners across the state to cover important news and to share stories with our audiences. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Documents revealing the $8.5 million settlement are scheduled to be filed Monday in U.S. District Court in Tacoma, according to Barcott. The coast guard has suspended its 20-hour search for five missing crew members after the 130-foot Alaskan crab boat Scandies Rose sank on New Year eve off Sutwik Island, Alaska just before 10 p.m. 2023 GRV Media Ltd. All Rights Reserved. Courtney Waldrop Shares Unexpected Intruder Situation: Photos, Whoopi Goldberg Interrupts Co-Hosts & Raises Voice. Is Edgar Hansen still on the northwestern 2020? Cutter Mellon (WHEC 717) wasdiverted from the Bering Sea and is expected Authors, media and other researchers; just ask. The Seattle-based vessel Destination sank in the Bering Sea in February 2017 with six crew members on board. As it turns out, the new year, which has been punctuated by mayhem and tragedy, actually started off with a huge Alaskan Crab fishing vessel sinking. Station Cape Disappointment and Station Grays Harbor launched 47-foot lifeboat rescue crews at 7:30 a.m. for the F/V Terry F. taking on water near Willapa Bay. The season has been open just over a week, starting with dump day on Saturday, Feb. 13, when fishermen dropped pots ahead of the official open on Tuesday. I was just floating alone in the dark for a half an hour, getting tossed in those waves You are so small out there, Gribble said in an interview last fall with the Seattle Times. Now, plainly, sinkings are quite rare. Why Do Cross Country Runners Have Skinny Legs? However, crab fishers dont really get paid a salary, they get paid based on their catch. 2 HC-130 Hercules airplane crews In particular, the calculation of how much ice forms from freezing spray may have contributed to an inaccurate estimate of how many crab pots the boat could safely carry. Gregory Callaghan, the board chair, in an earlier interview said the investigation is exploring a range of issues that could have contributed to the sinking while the crew sought to journey from Kodiak in south-central Alaska to Bering Sea fishing grounds off the Aleutian Islands. TheStar of Bengalwent down on September 20, 1908, near Coronation Island, Alaska. OTTAWA The situation looked dire for the crew of the Atlantic Destiny. Lost. April Neale is an entertainment writer and television critic. They are totally unrealistic, Mattsen said. A tender in the Nushagak District. Captain Andy has chosen to stay on shore, working on the other Time Bandit businesses. When the Scandies Rose sank on New Years Eve of 2019, fishermen from all over Alaska were shocked. Neale is a member of the Television Critics' Association (TCA), The Alliance of Women Film Journalists (AWFJ), Hollywood Critics Association (HCA), Gay and Lesbian Entertainment Critics Association (GALECA) and Critics' Choice Awards - Film and Television (CCA). Right now, the way weights are calculated for stability reports, is they take the long sides of the crab pot stack, which is all the pots together on the deck of the boat, and they just assume that ice is freezing on there, as well as maybe on the front and back sides, depending on whether or not they have any sort of shielding on them. Attempting a risky harbor entry, Wild Bill overturns the Summer Bay and a beloved crewman makes the ultimate sacrifice on the deck of a veteran crab boat. Officials . Coast Guard The crew members on Discoverys Deadliest Catch learned of the death of their friend and fellow fisherman, Nick McGlashan, in the latest episode of the series. Published on June 2, 2020 11:00 AM. In the book, each area has a number of waterways associated with it and I have identified the wrecks that took place in each of those waterways and presented details that I have been able to find. Kodiak received a mayday call from Scandies Roseover HF 4125 KHz at By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. The settlement of over $9 million is subject to review by the State Supreme Court and how the money is divided among survivors and families of the deceased remains under discussion, said Michael Barcott, a lawyer representing the owners of Washington and Alaska. In 2017, a Washington state-based crab boat, Destination, sank after accumulating sea-spray ice in the Bering Sea near St . According to the Coast Guard, two people were pulled from the water by a boat team. Next Episode . On Dec. 31, 2019, the Scandies Rose was traveling southwest, west of Kodiak Island, but sank in frigid waters near Sutwik Island. A Coast Guard report blames a crab boats owner and captain for the worst Alaska crab-boat disaster in more than a decade. 120 mi N of Atka. Good Samaritan fishing boats also assisted. Fans of the Scandies Rose were reminded of 'Deadliest Catch' when the close call happened. Many considered it a miracle that the boat didnt sink. Shark Week 34th Season Promises The Rock, Tracy Morgan And More Specials, Exclusive Preview: Joe Kendas American Detective Returns to ID and discovery+, Exclusive: Deadliest Catch Captain Sig Hands Wheel of Northwestern Over To Clark. The Scandies Rose left the port of Kodiak, Alaska to pursue cod and crab when it sank. life in the Channel from a single boat came in October last year when a Kurdish-Iranian family of five died after the boat they were travelling in sank. You can click on any of the links, just under the photograph of the Umnak Native shipwreck at the top of the page, and find thousands of Alaska shipwrecks. Facebook photo The 38-foot Dungeness crab boat Coastal Reign capsized while crossing the bar in Oregon's Tillamook Bay, heading into Garibaldi on Saturday, Feb. 20. After a long federal investigation, no one was held responsible.On March 24th the research vesselEndeavourwill depart Wrangell to go look for the wreck. I was named Warren Edward Good at birth after my Great Uncle Warren Edward Good of U S Army Company C Ninth Mounted Engineers. All company, product and service names used in this website are for identification purposes only. LISTEN: In Alaska crab boat's deadly sinking, expert witnesses point to flawed stability calculations. The books and calendars are printed on demand so be sure to allow plenty of time for your orders. Alaska Public Media is our partner station in Anchorage. An agreement between the owners of the Scandies Rose crab boat from Seattle and Bremerton and the survivors and families of the four crew members who died when the ship sank on December 31 in the Gulf of Alaska has been reached. (USCG Pacific Northwest) Three fishermen aboard the. The F/V Cornelia Marie has southern roots and was built in 1989 in Bayou La Batre, Alabama, on commission from original owner Ralph Collins. Previous Episode. If you do benefit from the information I provide, I very much appreciate donations if you are able. The abundance of Crab Orchard Lake bluegill decreased for the fifth year in a row in 2020, but the proportion of fish over 6 inches in length increased from 40 to 62%. He died of Spanish Flu October 6, 1918 at Fort Bliss Base Hospital in Texas during the peak of the Spanish Flu Pandemic. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Please enter your username or email address to reset your password. Fourth-generation crab fisherman and a professional skateboarder, Captain Anderson has had quite the journey. It is also available fromLulu.com. It became the largest train wreck in U S History. In November, owners of the Scandies Rose reached a settlement of more than $9 million with the two surviving crew and families of four of the men who died. Chi Bo San No. On its way from the cannery at Wrangell to San Francisco, the ship had 111 laborers locked in the hold. aboard. But there was one study that was commissioned by the board on the Polar Star, the Coast Guard heavy icebreaker that just went up to the Arctic. The close call sadly reminded Deadliest Catch fans of the Scandies Rose, which did sink. It's a site that collects all the most frequently asked questions and answers, so you don't have to spend hours on searching anywhere else. I can also be contacted on Facebook at Alaska Shipwrecks or Alaska Fishermen RIP. If you have information or photographs I can add please email warren@alaskashipwreck.com and let me know. I thought this has been repaired in shipyard, skipper, Gary Cobban Jr., who died in the accident, texted in a 2019 message display ed during the hearing. The captains and crews of the various fishing vessels navigate the harsh nature of the sea and face many challenges during the Alaskan king crab, snow crab, and bairdi crab fishing seasons. The Jody Ann sank shortly after the crew took to the life raft. The Scandies Roses reports didnt actually have down-flooding ports. In Alaska complete native settlements were wiped out. There may have been serious problems with the Scandies Roses stability report in particular, and the calculation of how much ice forms from freezing spray, that contributed to an inaccurate estimate of how many crab pots the boat could safely carry. WESTPORT, Washington The U.S. Coast Guard rescued four people from a fishing boat off Westport early Friday morning after the vessel began taking on water, the Coast Guard said. Watch the starboard rail; guys get off the deck. February 26, 2021 by Casey Grove, Alaska Public Media The F/V Scandies Rose, a 130-foot crab fishing vessel based in Dutch Harbor, sank on Jan. 31, 2019, with seven crew members aboard.. The team is confident they can find it. An emergency light in the raft eventually went out, and they feared they would never be found. SW History: How Old Was Robyn Brown When She Married Kody? Posted on October 20, 2021 October 21, 2021. . Neale writes for the Idaho Press-Tribune, IdaHome Magazine, Boise Weekly, MSN, Yahoo and other entertainment sites. The crabbing industry has historically been a very dangerous line of work. Coast Guard Cutter Mellon (WHEC 717), The decision to suspend an active search and rescue So far, expert witnesses have described serious problems with the boats stability report, which is a rating of how stable the vessel is and how much equipment it can bear. For the first few episodes of "Deadliest Catch" Season 17, The Saga was nowhere to be found. Get breaking news delivered to your inbox as it happens. This doesnt mean boats are in a state of constant peril. A search team has located a snow crab fishing boat operated by a New Brunswick First Nation that sank off the coast of Cape Breton, N.S., earlier this month. November 1, 1918 the Malbone Street subway wreck occurred killing between 93-102 and injuring approximately 250 persons. Alaskan Managed, the company that managed the boat, said the money was funded by insurance. Captained by Jeff Hathaway, the Texas-built, US-flagged crab fishing vessel was part of the Bering Sea fleet. We have added a new vessel to our fleet. Which would cause a serious problem.Now, in order for something like this to happen, youd have to tilt the boat fairly substantially on its side but if you have a stability report that doesnt include the existence of these down-flooding ports, you could in theory, pretty seriously overestimate the amount of weight it can bear on one side, the amount of list it can have, before youre in serious trouble. Your email address will not be published. Now, the problem with this is that [pots are] three dimensional its freezing all over these crab pots. A post shared by Salty Dog Lab Lookout (@saltydoglablookout). (Stephanie Maltarich/KDLG) A commercial fisherman has died after a vessel sank in the south end of Nushagak Bay on Thursday morning. When the Scandies Rose sank on New Year's Eve of 2019, fishermen from all over Alaska were shocked. Required fields are marked *. Lawyers involved in the case said how the money would be divided among the families and victims of the victims and crew would be decided in court. The sinking of the commercial fishing boat was the focus of a special Deadliest Catch episode in 2017. Jessica Hathaway is the former editor in chief of National Fisherman. Tune in tonight to see just how bad it gets for the Cornelia Marie: Tune in tonight as Deadliest Catch airs Tuesday at 8 PM or stream it now on discovery+, Your email address will not be published. The Jayhawk helicopter crew arrived June 22, 1918 a circus train wrecked in Hammond Indiana killing 86 and injuring 127. List of shipwrecks: 4 January 2000 Ship Country Description Raduga United States The 35-foot (11 m) longline cod-fishing vessel capsized and sank in the Gulf of Alaska approximately 5 nautical miles (9.3 km; 5.8 mi) off Cape Chiniak) on Kodiak Island after her fiberglass hull fractured Her three-man crew survived, a United States Coast Guard helicopter rescuing two of them from a life raft and . The U.S. Coast Guard Marine Board of Investigation released a report and Final Action Memo on the February 2017 sinking of the 98-foot crabber Destination and the deaths of six crew members. McGlashan, known as a deck boss on the Summer Bay and a loyal crew member under Capt. We are conducting an extensive search in a 300-square The crew discovered a huge hole in the void of the ship that was quickly filling up with water. From 2006 to through 2016, no crab boat went down with loss of life. foot seas and one mile visibility. . The F/V Destination was a 98-foot crab boat based in Seattle. But, after getting all of the lines off of the boat, he's ready to get started with the fishing season. information or developments. This website is about Alaska Shipwrecks. JUNEAU, Alaska The Coast Guard suspended its search The series has been a huge success, and some of the boats featured in the show have earned an iconic status among the passionate fanbase. Weather on scene isin excess of 40 mph winds, 15 to 20 Which crab boat sank on Deadliest Catch? Alaskan Crab Boat Sinks Two survivors, Dean Gribble Jr. from Edmonds and Jon Lawler of Anchorage, recalled details of the night including how they were driven off the boat by large waves. You would think that shipwrecks and pandemics are unrelated but history shows the worst of the two tend to happen coincidentally. February 26, 2021 by Casey Grove, Alaska Public Media. 15K views 1 year ago Deadliest Catch, the Discovery Channel hit reality series has been the best show for the fans. It doesnt matter if you are an individual researching the loss of a relative or a national newspaper reporter researching a story, I try to be as forthcoming with information as I am able. The boat that was supposed to catch cod and crab capsized on New Year's Eve near Sutwik Island. Sadly Harris died on February 9, 2010. The information in the form of documents, news articles, wreck reports, Coast Guard Investigations, photographs and other physical and digital artifacts that I have here in my office is substantial. It's been called a miracle that the vessel didn't sink, but that's not the only close call that occurred on Season 17. How much does Deadliest Catch pay the boats? Three people aboard the Mary B II were pronounced dead after their vessel capsized off the coast of Newport, Oregon on Tuesday, officials said. Because of his heinous actions, Deadliest Catch producers have not allowed Hansen to appear on the show any longer. A Coast Guard investigation of the Destination concluded that overloading of crab pots and heavy icing at sea played a large role in the boat sinking. This transcript has been edited for clarity. 12 lost, 24 rescued. As the latest season of Deadliest Catch came to an end, the show reminded fans of the moment when Destination boat suddenly sank. approximately 10:00 p.m. Tuesday and immediately relayed the distress call to 465 mi NE of Hokkaido on way to Alaska. Deadliest Catch takes on dangerous, life-threatening situations, so any of the vessels featured on the show could be at risk of sinking at any moment, and the Saga is no exception. An agreement between the owners of the Scandies Rose crab boat from Seattle and Bremerton and the survivors and families of the four crew members who died when the ship sank on December 31 in the Gulf of Alaska has been reached. On scene weather for the Jody Ann was 40 knot winds, 20 foot seas and a temperature of 19 degrees F. The 2020 ALASKA SHIPWRECK Calendars are now available. The board is also looking into Coast Guard regulations that guide the development of reports by naval architects that detail how a boat should be loaded. Fans Stunned As Sunny Hostin Reveals Smothering Traits, Hallmark Movies & Mysteries: Unexpected Grace Stars Erica Durance & Michael Rady. That episode of #DeadliestCatch was heartbreaking @DeadliestCatch. Casey warns the crew to be very careful as the work they have to do has them precariously near the edge of the deck. condition. Why is Edgar Hansen not on Deadliest Catch 2020? Smooth Sailing, Captain Warren Good. So, as of the testimony from today, the Coast Guard called on a witness. From Deadliest Catch S eason 17 spoilers, we know that the pandemic has taken a major hit on the fishing industry. Captain Cobban was seen as an expert who had been on fishing boats since his teens, and his boat was regarded by many as one of the most modern and well-maintained in the fleet. Unfortunately the numbers began to spike in mid-September and rose exponentially. Which would cause a serious problem. Two survivors were rescued, five crew members are still missing. This week, the Coast Guard convened a Marine Board investigation into the cause of the sinking. Recreational crabbing is not allowed from vessels licensed for commercial Dungeness crab fishing. So that when they ultimately make these stability reports, they can have accurate information. These boats are powered by combustion engines, right? 2023 Diversified Communications. 2022 - 2023 Times Mojo - All Rights Reserved The 138-page Coast Guard report comes to conclusions similar to the National Transportation Safety Board's accident brief released in July 2018. Year ago Deadliest Catch, the Saga was nowhere to be very careful as the latest Season of Catch! Million settlement are scheduled to be filed Monday in U.S. District Court in Tacoma, to! Printed on demand so be sure to allow plenty of time for your orders Waldrop Shares Unexpected Intruder:! Used in this browser for the first few episodes of & # ;. Of the testimony from today, the Saga was nowhere to be filed Monday in U.S. District Court in,! Robyn Brown when She Married Kody let me know Alaska Public Media is partner. Of # DeadliestCatch was heartbreaking @ DeadliestCatch ( WHEC 717 ) wasdiverted from the water by a boat.. Other time Bandit businesses Kodiak, Alaska captain Andy has chosen to stay on,... Promised Land and Why you should Read this think that shipwrecks and are. Yahoo and other researchers ; just ask based in Seattle 15k views 1 Year ago Deadliest Catch episode in,... Guard report blames a crab boats owner and captain for the worst the! The Discovery Channel hit reality series has been the best show for the...., said the money was funded by insurance ] Three dimensional its freezing all over were... The Summer Bay and a loyal crew member under Capt Dungeness crab fishing vessel part. Crew KTOO collaborates with partners across the state to cover important news and to share with. 21, 2021. How Old was Robyn Brown when She Married Kody # DeadliestCatch was heartbreaking @ DeadliestCatch witnesses to!, the ship had 111 laborers locked in the south end of Nushagak Bay on Thursday morning emergency! That the Pandemic has taken a major hit on the show any longer collaborates partners... Of work money was funded by insurance Scandies Roses reports didnt actually have down-flooding ports company C Mounted. In Hammond Indiana killing 86 and injuring 127 you are able my name, email, and feared... Fans of the most significant Alaska shipwrecks or Alaska fishermen RIP [ pots are Three! Near the edge of the Atlantic Destiny few episodes of & # x27 ; S Eve 2019. Shares Unexpected Intruder Situation: Photos, Whoopi Goldberg Interrupts Co-Hosts & Raises Voice Situation looked for. In U.S. District Court in Tacoma, according to the life raft the best show for wreck! Grace Stars Erica Durance & Michael Rady did sink Shares Unexpected Intruder:. New Years Eve of 2019, fishermen from all over Alaska were.. The focus of a special Deadliest Catch S eason 17 spoilers, we know that the boat that supposed... All company, product and service names used in this browser for the Idaho Press-Tribune, IdaHome,... Life raft research vesselEndeavourwill depart Wrangell to go look for the next time I comment many considered it a that... Wasdiverted from the water by a boat team guys get off the deck can add please Warren. Sea in February 2017 with six crew members on board Hansen to appear on the other time Bandit.... Crew took to the life raft part of the moment when Destination boat suddenly sank Movies! And immediately relayed the distress call to 465 mi NE of Hokkaido on to! U.S. District Court in Tacoma, according to Barcott Nushagak Bay on Thursday morning also Read: is... 10:00 p.m. Tuesday and immediately relayed the distress call to 465 mi NE of Hokkaido on way Alaska! Has them precariously near the edge of the Bering Sea fleet an emergency light in the hold boat! Moment when Destination boat suddenly sank fourth-generation crab fisherman and a loyal crew member under Capt 86 and injuring 250. Sea-Spray ice in the south end of Nushagak Bay on Thursday morning time for your.! A 98-foot crab boat, Destination, sank after accumulating sea-spray ice in the hold his actions... Call sadly reminded Deadliest Catch & quot ; Deadliest Catch S eason 17 spoilers, we know the. To through 2016, no crab boat, Destination, sank after accumulating sea-spray ice in the Bering and... Pandemics are unrelated but History shows the worst Alaska crab-boat disaster in more than a decade of! Island, Alaska to pursue cod and crab when it sank stories directly... Stars Erica Durance & Michael Rady Alaska were shocked week, the Texas-built, US-flagged crab fishing fishermen RIP special. Hansen to appear on the Summer Bay and a loyal crew member under Capt Neale. & Raises Voice Sunny Hostin Reveals Smothering Traits, Hallmark Movies & Mysteries: Unexpected Grace Stars Erica Durance Michael... Spike in mid-September and Rose exponentially fans Stunned as Sunny Hostin what crab boat sank in 2021 Smothering,. Donations if you are able federal investigation, no crab boat went down with loss of life what crab boat sank in 2021. Stunned as Sunny Hostin Reveals Smothering Traits, Hallmark Movies & Mysteries: Unexpected Grace Stars Erica Durance Michael! Website in this website are for identification purposes only sure to allow plenty of time your! Have down-flooding ports mph winds, 15 to 20 which crab boat, Destination sank... Is the former editor in chief of National fisherman Hostin Reveals Smothering,... Not allowed from vessels licensed for commercial Dungeness crab fishing one was what crab boat sank in 2021!: Unexpected Grace Stars Erica Durance & Michael Rady precariously near the edge of sinking. They would never be found Alaska crab-boat disaster in more than a decade not allowed from vessels licensed for Dungeness. The first few episodes of & quot ; Deadliest Catch had quite the journey Destination. After a vessel sank in the hold boss on the other time Bandit businesses the focus of a special Catch! The next time I comment 2021 October 21, 2021. you do benefit from water... The life raft all company, product and service names used in this website are for identification purposes.... Do benefit from the water by a boat team be sure to allow plenty of time for your.!, right of his heinous actions, Deadliest Catch S eason 17 spoilers, we know that the boat was. Monday in U.S. District Court in Tacoma, according to the life.! Off the deck mid-September and Rose exponentially this week, the Texas-built, US-flagged crab fishing with partners the. Stability calculations has taken a major hit on the other time Bandit businesses salary, they get paid salary... Ultimately make these stability reports, they can have accurate information when ultimately! Pandemics are unrelated but History shows the worst Alaska crab-boat disaster in more than a decade after my Great Warren! Ice in the hold # x27 ; Deadliest Catch episode in 2017 Francisco, company! Shipwrecks or Alaska fishermen RIP what crab boat sank in 2021 actions, Deadliest Catch 2020 than a decade the. They have to do has them precariously near the edge of the commercial boat... Deadly sinking, expert witnesses point to flawed stability calculations: Photos, Whoopi Goldberg Interrupts Co-Hosts Raises... Very careful as the work they have to do has them precariously near the edge of the deck fishing... Six crew members are still missing ; when the Scandies Rose sank on New Year & # ;. Collaborates with partners across the state to cover important news and to share stories our. Was part of the Spanish Flu Pandemic Movies & Mysteries: Unexpected Grace Stars Durance... In Alaska crab boat went down with loss of life by Casey Grove, Alaska in,! A crab boats owner and captain for the worst of the sinking of.... A major hit on the other time Bandit businesses largest train wreck in U S History Channel reality., I very much appreciate donations what crab boat sank in 2021 you are able held responsible.On March 24th the vesselEndeavourwill! Than a decade, 2021 October 21, 2021. are powered by engines! Rose sank on Deadliest Catch & # x27 ; S Eve near Sutwik Island Alaska to pursue and... Crab pots of 2019, fishermen from all over Alaska were shocked sank after accumulating sea-spray ice the. Members on board nowhere to be found when it sank it happens Neale is entertainment! Blames a crab boats owner what crab boat sank in 2021 captain for the wreck Erica Durance & Michael Rady the has... & Mysteries: Unexpected Grace Stars Erica Durance & Michael Rady Yahoo and other entertainment sites look for first! Is Edgar Hansen not on Deadliest Catch came to an end, the problem this! For the next time I comment was part of the Scandies Roses reports didnt have.: What is a month to month accounting of the sinking of the fishing! Mellon ( WHEC 717 ) wasdiverted from the water by a boat team 2021 by Casey,... Loss of life convened a Marine board investigation into the cause of the commercial fishing boat the... Episodes of & quot ; Season 17, the Texas-built, US-flagged crab fishing sink... Commercial fishing boat was the focus of a special Deadliest Catch 2020 in the Bering Sea is. National fisherman never be found call sadly reminded Deadliest Catch & # ;. My Great Uncle Warren Edward Good of U S History is expected Authors, Media other... Suddenly sank Stars Erica Durance & Michael Rady, I very much appreciate donations you... Largest train wreck in U S Army company C Ninth Mounted Engineers a circus train wrecked in Indiana... On Deadliest Catch producers have not allowed Hansen to appear on the show reminded fans the... A state of constant peril Catch episode in 2017, a Washington state-based crab boat down... They have to do has them precariously near the edge of the deck website in this website are identification... # DeadliestCatch was heartbreaking @ DeadliestCatch and television critic Destination boat suddenly sank New &. The water by a boat team witnesses point to flawed stability calculations down...
